The Clandestine Economy of Music Leaking
Hide your hard drives.
November 18, 2026
BY Eden DaSilva

Design by Tyler Farmer
Hide your hard drives.
November 18, 2026
BY Eden DaSilva
Before finally surfacing online this October, Kanye West and Jay-Z’s “Living So Italian” had only been heard by a select few journalists sitting on the floor of a New York City hotel room in 2011. The exclusive listening party, hosted by Hov himself, had a strict no phone policy—their highly-anticipated collab album Watch The Throne wasn’t set to release for another month, and many of the project's details were still under tight wraps.
As Jay-Z debuted the Andrea Bocelli-sampling track inside the Mercer Hotel, a writer from The FADER attempted to live-tweet their reaction. They were promptly ejected from the room, and later referred to as an “idiot” by a writer from GQ, who described the track as a “hilarious” and “audacious” highlight of the project in his review. The incident only added further to the track’s mythology after it was found absent from the album’s official iTunes tracklist: Bocelli had allegedly refused to clear the sample. Online, fans quickly discovered that Lil B had already rapped over the beat a year prior on his Red Flame mixtape before it somehow ended up in the hands of Mike Dean.
Amongst the legions of hardcore Kanye obsessives on forums, subreddits, and Discord groups, the track was long considered one of the holy grails of his extensive unreleased catalogue. In May of 2019, a brief low-quality snippet believed to have been secretly recorded during the listening party began circulating online. Though the audio was a glimmer of hope, most still believed it was nearly impossible that a studio version would ever see the light of day.

Screenshot provided by author
Ten days after joining and interviewing core members of a Discord group dedicated to Kanye West’s unreleased music, I received a notification: a $23,000 group buy for the full version of “Living So Italian” had been announced, with additional tracks from names including Future, Ed Sheeran, Destroy Lonely, Akon, JID, and Jim Legxacy to be released as they grew closer to their fundraising goal.
“Someone hit me up with access to Jay-Z and Kanye’s hard drives from that era,” one of the organizers of the sale explained in a private message, adding that their source had to have gotten their hands on the physical hard drives, as the project’s closely-guarded recording process pre-dated the hackable cloud storage accounts used by artists today.
Back in the era of Watch The Throne, when physical releases still constituted a large portion of album sales, Kanye West and Jay-Z’s exclusive deal with iTunes and Best Buy drew criticism from independent record stores worldwide, but their efforts paid off. The project made headlines across the music world for miraculously not leaking early to piracy sites, where virtually every major release typically circulated well in advance.
Ever since the dawn of online filesharing in the ‘90s, rap music—the preferred genre of internet-savvy males aged 15 to 30—has been hit the hardest by leaks. Long before the age of group buys and untraceable internet money, terminally-online hip-hop heads have gotten their hands on new music from their favorite artists by any means necessary.

Simon Tai
In October of 2000, 21-year-old biology student Simon Tai walked into the mail room of his job at the University of Pennsylvania’s radio station. A promotional copy of the new Outkast CD had just arrived in advance of its upcoming Halloween release date. Throughout his first few years of college, Tai’s passion for music had earned him a reputation across campus as the go-to DJ for parties, but on this night, he had other plans.
Racing back home, he popped the album into his computer and logged into the private chat room of Rabid Neurosis (RNS), one of the most infamous music piracy crews in a loosely-affiliated network known as “The Scene.” Thanks to Tai, known online by his screen name “RST,” Rabid Neurosis had recently leaked Ludacris’s commercial debut, Back for the First Time, two weeks before its official release. In just a few hours, Outkast’s Stankonia would be added to their growing list of accolades.
During this more primitive age of the internet, The Scene operated within anonymous channels of communication known as IRC (Internet Relay Chat), structured similarly to the modern Discord groups of today. Before the introduction of public filesharing websites like Napster and Limewire, these chat rooms were the best place for aspiring online pirates to access expansive libraries of free music, movies, and software. Tai had been involved in various MP3 piracy channels since 1997, and after a few months of participation in the RNS network, their leader had extended him an invitation to officially join their ranks. The group had become particularly focused on acquiring pre-release music, and Tai’s insider access as the radio station’s music director was an invaluable asset to the crew. By his senior year of college in 2000, Tai had been promoted to a leadership role as the group’s “ripping coordinator”.
“It was almost like we were running a company, but we didn’t get paid for it. There was structure and leadership, deadlines, and strict operational procedures,” Tai explained over a video call. “My mindset was that because I wasn’t making money off this, it was okay.”
As an aspiring young DJ, the exclusive and unlimited access to free music available to vetted members of The Scene was more than enough to justify the time and effort it required. Now 46-years-old, he’s found success as a working DJ playing weddings and events including Bruno Mars' 24K Magic World Tour, and the 2016 Democratic National Convention afterparty. Looking back on his days of ripping music as “RST,” Tai considers the experience a foundational part of who he’s become today.
“As I joined that community, it became a social thing, there was always an aspect of competition between all the other groups. That was a big part of it for me,” he said. “There used to be a system recording everything that leaked, and who leaked it.”
By the year 2000, nearly every big release was available within Scene networks weeks (and sometimes months) early, oftentimes thanks to members of RNS. “There were people that worked at radio stations, music writers, employees at Tower Records or Blockbuster—I think for a lot of us, it was pride and ego. We didn’t play sports, but this was our way of battling it out.”
In addition to major hip-hop records including The Eminem Show, The College Dropout, 500 Degreez, and The Blueprint, RNS was responsible for leaking 50 Cent’s unreleased debut project Power of the Dollar, which had been permanently shelved after the rapper was shot nine times and subsequently dropped by Columbia Records. In retrospect, Tai speculates that he could have burned bootleg CDs as a veritable college sidehustle, but explains that a strict code of ethics amongst Scene participants held him back from doing so.
“Back then, the leaders of the groups formed a council and made rules for the whole Scene. One big thing was that nobody was supposed to profit off this. We thought of ourselves as the Robin Hoods bringing music to the people—we were doing this for the love of the game.”
By 2003, Tai had mostly stepped away from his involvement in ripping music for RNS. Scene groups still offered the earliest access to ripped music, but much of it was now finding its way onto public platforms like Napster, or a newly-introduced BitTorrent website called The Pirate Bay. With recent advancements in peer-to-peer technology and digital piracy’s explosion in popularity, a slow transition towards more user-friendly communities had begun.
Compared to the strict release guidelines enforced by The Scene, many of the public filesharing websites were an organizational free-for-all, and their open nature made users easy targets for entertainment lawyers. Private torrent trackers like OinK’s Pink Palace and its successor What.CD were created to uphold these traditions, adopting similar rulesets regarding membership, audio quality, file-naming conventions, and cataloguing. These new communities thrived within their IRC channels and forums, and thanks to a constantly growing userbase, pre-release rips were hitting the internet as early as ever. Much like The Scene’s system of incentivized participation, users of these private communities were required to maintain minimum ratios of data uploaded and downloaded, and becoming the first to upload highly-anticipated releases became a competition, rewarded with large bounties of crowdsourced upload credits.
As online streaming services reached mass adoption throughout the 2010s, even fans willing to pay for music no longer needed to line up outside record stores. CD sales plummeted, and by the end of 2014, Billboard began counting streams towards their chart calculations. With record labels no longer relying on physical sales to boost first-week numbers, having CDs available in-store the day of release was no longer a priority. As a result, the timeframe of pre-release leaks was cut to mere days in advance, if at all.
For a brief moment, it felt as if major album leaks had become a thing of the past, rendered obsolete by an evolving digital landscape. Little did the industry suits know, their moment of peace and quiet wouldn’t last for long.

Screenshot provided by author
On June 2nd, 2017, a group of hackers gained access to Drake’s Twitter, hijacking his account long enough to post a link that quickly circulated across hip-hop blogs: MusicMafia.to. On the site’s homepage, MusicMafia boasted access to a massive archive of unreleased music from some of the industry’s biggest names—a claim they backed by sharing an alternate version of “Slide” by Frank Ocean & Calvin Harris, as well as Kanye West’s “Hold Tight” featuring Migos and Young Thug.
While recordings from scrapped projects surfacing online years later was nothing new, the motivation behind MusicMafia’s high-profile leaks was different from generations past. In addition to the initial tracks shared for free, their website listed a number of songs locked behind public paywalls: each track was tied to a Bitcoin address, only to be released in full once their asking price was met through fan-driven crowdfunding.
As an increasing frequency of DMCA takedowns pushed leak discussion and download links off of public subreddits and forums, fans migrated to Discord. Much like the various Scene groups that congregated away from the public eye in IRC networks, dozens of communities sprung up. Rather than adopting names like Rabid Neurosis or Apocalypse Production Crew, groups now are often focused on one artist in particular.
In order to get a closer look into today’s unreleased underworld, I joined nearly a dozen Discord groups dedicated to rappers with notoriously leaky catalogues including Young Thug, Playboi Carti, and Juice WRLD.
After nearly two weeks of investigative dead ends and accusations of working with the feds, I finally found myself speaking with the group of Kanye West fans who would soon middle-man the sale of “Living So Italian.” Through our initial introductions, I learned that most of them are in their early 20s—albums like Donda and Jesus Is King are mentioned as their earliest exposure to the rapper. Rather than his officially released material, their obsession seemed to revolve around leaked songs from unreleased projects, and demo versions of completed tracks.
“I like to see the creation of things,” one of them said in a group call. “Maybe one day, I’ll get to hear the original version of Vultures…It’s like an archival project, in the same way that people like lost media. They want what they can't have, like a forbidden fruit. Why make art that never sees the light of day if there’s people who would enjoy it? Even if the artist thinks it’s garbage, one man's trash is another man's treasure.”
Another voice chimed in. “If you really want to look into the history of Ye group buys, you really need to check out the tracker.” They then directed me to a spreadsheet-style website cataloguing hundreds of Kanye West group buys in extensive detail, dating all the way back to MusicMafia’s listing of “Pressure (Can U Be)” in June of 2017.

Screenshot of the Ye Tracker
Another user, seemingly the most senior of the group, offered some background history on the monetization of this culture. “A lot of the leaks from The Life of Pablo were all tracks that the guy who owned [the hip-hop forum] Section Eighty had paid for and posted. People had been selling stuff privately for years—they just didn’t do anything publicly because they assumed it was a niche interest, and that not a lot of people would be willing to spend money on that kind of stuff. Once MusicMafia proved that you could consistently sell tracks for thousands of dollars, that was it.”
“Cybercrime peaked when crypto started becoming a thing,” he continued, “making it easier to funnel money anonymously. When [selling] music became more lucrative, a lot of people came over from the fraud community, and [the leaking market] became a new haven for cybercriminals.” According to a group buy tracker for Juice WRLD, fans have spent a collective total of two million dollars on music from the late rapper's extensive vault, with individual tracks fetching prices of up to $30,000.
Today, most of the music circulating through these communities is acquired through criminal methods like phishing, SIM swapping, and social engineering. “It used to not be like this,” he said. “You had to get your hands on a CD or steal a computer. Producers and engineers using Dropbox and iCloud to store stuff changed things, because hackers just have to get into their account to obtain the files. Now, it’s probably 90% hacking and only 10% people leaking stuff from the inside.”
The group explains that in many cases of insider leaks, someone from the artists camp will reach out to admins of Discord groups like theirs to facilitate a sale. “One example that I can think of is during the Cuck era, someone from Kanye's team came to us and basically said, ‘I want to sell this with all the profits going to the Holocaust Museum, because I don't feel like this is right.’ It was leaked on purpose to fuck up the rollout and stop it from officially coming out. We made a group buy and raised $999. It was all donated.”

Photo provided by author
In January of 2025, one of Eminem’s longtime engineers Joseph Strange was visited by the FBI after more than 25 unreleased tracks surfaced online. According to investigators, Strange received at least $50,000 in Bitcoin through sales of the material. Online, fans have accused other producers involved with Juice WRLD and Playboi Carti of selling unreleased music through group buys and private sales.
Though many artists have spoken out about leaks affecting them both financially and creatively, the young leakers don’t seem to feel any sort of moral conflict about this. “As much as people bemoan leaking, it keeps your name out there, it keeps people wanting to hear stuff from you. The hype for Whole Lotta Red wouldn't have been what it was if not for stuff leaking. With how long these rollouts take, there’s benefits to having your name out there.”
In the case of large group buys like the $23,000 sale of “Living So Italian,” the members of the call emphasized that none of the proceeds of the sales are lining their own pockets. I have no way to officially verify these claims, but I’m inclined to believe them. “How the fuck would I explain that money to my parents and the IRS?” one of them asked.
“We don’t wanna end up like King Bob,” said another, referencing the highly-publicized case of 20-year-old music leaker Noah Urban, who was recently sentenced to 10 years in federal prison for identity theft and wire fraud. Though they see no issue with leakers that choose to make a profit, the more criminal methods of acquiring crypto employed by some of the biggest spenders within the community is where they seem to draw the line. “If you’re committing bank fraud, you’re directly taking money from someone. But just because a song leaks, that doesn’t mean [the artist] can’t put it out. They can still make a lot of money.”
Surprisingly, this loosely-defined credo mostly aligns with the ethics of Simon Tai and RNS. “Our justification was that we were promoting the artist by putting their music out there, we were doing the marketing for them. There were definitely some mental gymnastics that had to be done,” Tai laughed. After his retirement from The Scene nearly two decades ago, he eventually stopped keeping tabs on that side of the music world. Before our interview came to a close, I gave him a brief rundown of what I learned about the leakers of today, and their profit-driven modus operandi.
“I can see how people paying money into these group buys is not only because they want to hear the song, but because they want to be part of that experience,” he said. “When the tracks get released they're probably thinking, ‘I had a part in that, I was associated with that track's history.’”
“On the surface, I can say those people who are stealing [music] from Dropboxes and phishing and scamming, that's worse—but is it really? You're both breaking the law, doing something that you're not supposed to be doing. It was probably easier to justify back when we did it, having access to those CDs was a byproduct of what we did, as opposed to now where they’re actively going and breaking into things. But fundamentally, I think it's the same. Even though we had legitimate positions as journalists and in CD pressing plants, it was against the law to take what we had and release it. I guess the one big thing was the code we had back then, that nobody was supposed to profit off of this, where now, the overwhelming majority of the ecosystem is for profit.”
Even during my search for potential interviewees on Discord, my own motivations as a journalist were called into question by young leakers. “Are you profiting off these stories? Why do you do them?” one well-known Juice WRLD seller asked in response to my introductory message. In today’s age of hyper-monetization where nearly every facet of life—both online and offline—exists to generate profit, it’s hard to blame the new generation for throwing an archaic code of morals to the wayside.
“Everything’s been monetized now,” Tai agreed, admitting that he can understand why the culture he helped lay the foundations for has changed in this way. “If Bitcoin had been around back then, someone would have monetized it. People are greedy—myself included.”
I asked if this new technology would’ve persuaded him to sell music during his time in The Scene. He paused for a moment.
“I’ve always been a hustler, so probably.”